What’s “Legitimate” About Rape? A Review of Rape Girl

October 15, 2012
By

Not long ago, a Republican candidate for the U.S. Senate, Todd Akin, made a medically ludicrous and morally objectionable statement about “legitimate” rape and the chances of a woman becoming pregnant afterward. His remarks and the controversy afterward make the recent release of Alina Klein’s Rape Girl (namelos) especially timely and important. Klein’s short novel packs a big punch, as it explores the aftermath of a 16-year-old girl’s rape by a classmate.

Rape Girl opens on Thanksgiving, when Val has a breakdown. She reveals that after a wild party at her house while her parents were away, a boy from her class raped her. Readers learn that the night before the rape Val had gotten drunk and sick, and the next morning while she was hung over (and possibly still drunk), Adam gained entry to her house and violated her. It’s a case of the very common “acquaintance rape”—while Val liked Adam, the two were not going out. Nonetheless, Adam uses Val’s interest in him to claim that “she wanted it.”

Readers see how the system works against the victim, causing her to become a victim a second time. Val cannot return to school, but Adam continues to attend classes and enjoy his popularity. When she eventually does return, Val is known as “rape girl.” The school arranges for her to receive private tutoring in the class she shares with Adam. His friends lie to make her seem like a slut. Even her best friend shuns her. The authorities twist various aspects of the law to let Adam off the hook. Val has to come to a private closure in the absence of peer support or the rule of law.

Rape Girl is an unflinchingly realistic look at rape, violence, and the state of women’s rights today in the United States. It is both a cautionary tale for teenage girls and a wake-up call for a generation that has become all too complacent.

Tags: , , , ,

One Response to What’s “Legitimate” About Rape? A Review of Rape Girl

  1. October 16, 2012 at 10:37 am

    A great review, especially relevant due to our current political climate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About

The Pirate Tree is a collective of children's and young adult writers interested in children's literature and social justice issues. For editorial or administrative issues, or to contact any of the authors whose email addresses are unlisted, please contact J.L. Powers at the address below. If you have a book you'd like to recommend for a review or an interview subject, guest writer, or topic that you'd like to suggest, please contact J.L. Powers.

Ann: aangel [at] aol [dot] com
Nancy: wflood [at]hotmail [dot] com
Varian: vcj [at] varianjohnson [dot] com
E.M.: emkokie [at] gmail [dot] com
Lyn: lynml [at] me [dot] com
Peter: pmarino300 [at] yahoo [dot] com
J.L.: jlpowers [at] evaporites [dot] com

Mission Statement

The writers at The Pirate Tree seek to expose and discuss literature and writers for children and teenagers that delve into themes of social justice and social conscience. The title, “The Pirate Tree,” comes from a picture book that Lyn Miller-Lachmann once wrote about two children whose grandfathers fought on opposite sides of a war. The children were prohibited from going into each others’ yards, but they figured out a way to meet and play pirates together by climbing a tree with limbs and branches above both their yards. Like the story suggested, we are interested in books and writers that question and rebel against the status quo, argue for peace and reconciliation, take the side of the marginalized and powerless, and use creative solutions to overcome obstacles.

Social Widgets powered by AB-WebLog.com.